Poetry is a very subjective medium and can be difficult to critique. Here are a few notes to start us off. First, poets – please don’t explain your poem. Do let us know whether your poem is intended to be printed or performed, or both. All pieces of writing have good points – we need to hear these as well as what didn’t work for you.
Overall Personal Response:
- Give the poet a general impression of your personal response to the poem: How did the poem make you feel? Think? What thoughts, images, or ideas did it evoke in you? What was your interpretation of the poem? Who do you see as a good audience for this poem?
Detailed Critique Points:
- Title: Did the title suit the work? Did it add to it?
- Opening: Did the poem engage you from the outset? Do you feel it started in the right place? Is there a strong line you feel would make a better opening?
- Rhythm and rhyme: Were words and phrases long or short, and to what effect? How did the poem employ vowel sounds or consonants? Did the rhythm of the work suit the poem? Did it break down or overpower the work at any point? Was there a formal structure? If rhyming was used, where did it feel effortless? Where did it feel forced? Did the chosen rhyme scheme (or absence thereof) suit the poem? Would the poem work better as free verse?
- Word choice: Is there a strong sense of voice? Was the language florid? Straightforward? Modern? Archaic? How did that support the overall form/theme/mood of the poem? How was the poem’s syntax? Was there any awkward reversal of syntax to fit a rhyme scheme? Did the author use strong nouns and verbs? Was there much reliance on adverbs and adjectives? Did you have any favourite lines or phrases?
- Imagery, metaphor, simile, allegory: Did the poem contain any of these? Were they subtle? Obviously? Pleasant? Off-beat? Cliché? How did that work for you? Did the poem present any particularly evocative images, and did these images support the poem as a whole?
- Progression and ending: Did the poem give you the right sense of building towards a whole? Did it have a climax or turning point? Were you engaged throughout, or did your attention wander in places? Did the ending satisfy you?
For page (printed) poems:
The group members will read the poem ahead of time and make notes. At the meeting, it’s recommended that the author read their poem aloud given that poetry traces its roots to spoken word, and reading our poetry to an audience is a skill in itself. However, if you prefer for someone else in the group to read the poem, please let us know. In addition to the above, you may want to comment on:
- Line breaks and stanza breaks: Do they seem to have been put in the right places? Are they placed to pull the reader through the poem? Do any of the line breaks seem too short/long/arbitrary? How would placing them differently affect your reading of the poem?
- White space and other formatting: If the poem has been formatted for presentation, does the chosen format invite you to read?
For performed poems:
The author will perform the poem for the group. Please perform it exactly as you intend to on stage, including entry, any preamble, and exit. After this, there will be some time for silent reading and note-taking. In addition to the above, you may want to comment on:
- Voice projection and intonation: Could you hear the performer clearly? Is there any way they could modulate their voice for better effect?
- Pacing: Was the reading fast? Slow? Were there any pauses? Did the pacing of the performance suit the poem?
- Gestures: Did the performer use any gestures? How did this affect your experience of the performance?
- Stage presence: Did the performance command your attention? Do you feel the performer managed to get the most out of the poem?
For more information on Workshops, please have a look at: What Are Creative Writing Groups & How To Find The Right One For You
