Several people working with their laptops and notebooks on a wooden desk.
11. Collaboration 2. Health For Writers Blog Corners of Creativity Featured

What Are Creative Writing Groups & How To Find The Right One For You

What are writing/critique groups/workshops? They are a collection of writers who come together to critique each other’s work, aka give feedback on current works in progress. Writing groups are a sounding board for writing techniques, thoughts, mental health and a social setting for lonely writers. Throughout my writing journey, I have found writing groups to be essential in the continuous improvement of my work.


One of the biggest advantages of writing groups is that they see your work — and your writing style — develop over time. With that hindsight, members can comment on your continued improvement and steer you clear of any pitfalls early on. But it’s not a one-way street. By critiquing their work and listening to other member’s reviews, you learn how to spot mistakes, analyse and edit your own work. It is easy to spot and reveal others’ mistakes, which makes it easier to find the faults in your own prose when they appear. All together, this creates a sense of community and friendship. But it can also be the reason why some groups fail.

My first experiences with workshops:

When I started my writing journey, I did not know what creative writing groups were. I was always under the impression that I just wrote what I needed to and handed it to a professor to handle. In year one of my MFA in Creative Writing course in the UK, we had 50% theory lectures and 50% workshops that were divided into smaller groups. In year two, and with a much smaller intake of writers, we had around 10% theory and 90% workshops. A few months later, we understood the reason for the large discrepancy. With continuous giving and receiving of feedback, the discussions, and the passive learning from watching others receive feedback, all of us improved our writing tenfold. The writing we produced at the start of the year versus what we wrote at the end of the year was markedly different. And we were proud of it.  

So how were the sessions structured? Every month, each student needed to produce between two and three pieces of work with a specific word count for their genre. With a set schedule, each student sent their work to the group several days in advance to allow everyone time to read.

For the first year, critique sessions were easy to handle. We could not say the same for year two. During the first workshop in year two, our professor, whom I had already known in year one, asked, “Who would like to be the sacrificial lamb?” Without missing a beat, I volunteered, not realising what I had just put myself into.

The session was brutal. Our professor ripped apart my work, highlighted every error in punctuation and grammar. And then did a deep dive into the meaning I was trying to convey and why certain sentences made no sense. By the end of the meeting, the women in my group hugged and comforted me while the men gave words of encouragement. Over year two, we comforted each other when we got a bad review. You will often hear writers say you need to have thick skin in this business, and this is why.

Once the critique session was over, students let their work rest. Mostly to calm their own nerves down.

One thing I need to clarify is that these reviews were not cruel. No one attacked the writers. There is a fine line between critiquing the writer and critiquing the work. And the class never crossed that line. This is one of the other reasons some writing groups fail: members do not know how to critique, and the head of the group hasn’t taught them.

After we left university to return to our respective countries, we kept up the workshops in our hometowns or online.

Now, a professor-led workshop performed effectively. But once we left the nest and entered the real world, we realised that not all workshops offered the same quality. Some of us met unpleasant hosts who were rude and vindictive. We also met members who learned bad habits from their previous groups and tried to transfer them to their new ones.

The Singapore Writer’s Network:

In 2016, I arrived in Singapore and found the Singapore Writer’s Network. Once I became a co-host of the SWN, I helped guide members in the right direction along with other hosts with similar backgrounds. We had some bumpy moments, especially when new members attacked the writer instead of the work.

Here are some examples:

  • “I don’t like this work.”
  • “The writer is lazy for writing in such a style.”
  • “I think you shouldn’t be making these mistakes because you’re an adult.”
  • “You are wrong.”
  • “You don’t know what you’re writing.”

I’ve taken such members aside or contacted them privately to teach them how to critique properly. The other hosts and I created a file for members to help guide them in their writing process, which you can find her:

One of our long-time SWN members shared how their hosts targeted them simply because the host disliked their story. The host insisted no readers would ever read their work and tried to belittle them in front of everyone else. Another member said their teacher taught them that they should be blunt and brutal in their feedback.

Now, giving and receiving critique is a skill that needs to be honed by practice. As you can see, there are certain lines that should never be crossed.

How to find a good writing workshop:

Look around and ask. Try to contact some members to get their take on the group and how they function. A good workshop should have rules in place, meet regularly, and have a host who knows what they are doing. Find a group that’s been around for a while. If you cannot find a local group, shop online. This will make it easier to research the group, but it will mean fewer face-to-face interactions. Do not make any promises. Try the group and see if you click with them before you commit.

Role of the host:

The host needs to be polite and fair, and must keep the peace, especially when a member crosses the line. Their role includes stopping members from attacking the writer and redirecting them to offer constructive criticism of the work. They need to lead by example, but they also need to give members a chance to give feedback without hogging all the limelight. They need to keep time and make sure that a member doesn’t go on a monologue/tryst. Hosts need to provide reasonable rules and enforce them whenever necessary.

Useful techniques in workshops:

Submissions should be sent in ahead of time to give everyone a chance to read the work.

One technique that I learned in class was the silent author method. The author of the work remains mute while listening to raw, unaffected feedback from the other members. If the author explains themselves, this affects the comments of the next member to talk, and the author robs themselves of honest feedback. Once a novel is published, the author cannot go to every reader and explain things to them. The work needs to stand on its own, and this technique simulates this.

Another important point is for members to be honest in their feedback. It’s ok to say, ‘I do not read so-and-so genre, and I am not your target audience, so here is my review as a general reader.’ This is where variety comes into play. The author will hear feedback from their target audience and different ethnicities, genders and age groups to get a better understanding of how their writing affects said groups.

Not all the feedback you receive will be useful to you. With a variety of readers, some will not have the experience of other readers. For example, a science fiction reader will have a very different take on Pride and Prejudice compared to a general fiction reader. And a general fiction reader will see Lord of the Rings in a different light from a fantasy reader. Always take critiques with a grain of salt. Politely accept what your fellow member says, and then work with what applies to your work.

Role of the member:

Members need to read all the submissions, not just the ones they like. This is a group activity with community efforts. Our shared goal is to help each other. Even if you are not submitting, your feedback helps the writer. And it helps you learn what to do and what not to do if you are writing similar work, scenes or characters. Everyone benefits. Your participation is vital to everyone’s education and improvement. I once had to ask a member why they were only critiquing specific members. They said they only read the submissions of members they liked and refused to read the rest. I helped them understand how this weakens the group and themselves. If we all read just what we wanted, we would not learn, and some members might not get the feedback they need. Variety is the spice of life, and the range of readers improves prose.

By telling a member what you understood and didn’t understand, where you found mistakes, or by giving suggestions, you assist them in seeing what they got right and what they need to improve. This is why members are often called Alpha Readers.

The reasons workshops are essential for writers:

  • A good group will help you achieve greater clarity, better prose and smoother pacing in your work. Your characters will shine and will be distinct and memorable. Your plot is easy to follow, and your readers are constantly engaged. A bad group will not help you. They would bring you down and demoralise you.
  • Oftentimes, writers procrastinate. A writing group keeps you accountable.
  • Non-writers think writing is easy. A writing group will be there for you to advise and cheer you on. They can become your tribe since they are people who will understand what you are going through.
  • The immediate feedback teaches you so much more than doing a solo writing course. Writing and sharing your work for feedback places you in a vulnerable position. A good group can be fun, trustworthy, and a place where you can feel safe to make mistakes among like-minded people.

The reasons why some groups fail:

Some groups fail or disband because of failed friendships. In the SWN, we lost some dear members because of infighting. These things happen and are unavoidable. What happens outside the group is beyond the host’s control.

A bad host who believes that the group is their own personal playground does no one any good. A host who only likes their genre and dismisses others is helping no one but themselves.

Final words:

Finding a group that works for you is essential in your writing journey. Whether it’s in person or online, you need to feel safe to share your work and receive feedback. Respect and dignity go a long way.

At the end of the day, receiving feedback is very difficult, so emotions run high. Before you make any judgments, take a step back and assess whether someone critiqued your work properly or attacked you. Then decide if this is the right group for you.


Image by StartupStockPhotos from Pixabay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *