It can be difficult to identify just what is not quite working out in a story and how to help its author bring it to the next level. Here are some notes to get you started.
Part One: Etiquette and General Approach
Etiquette
- Feedback is a conversation: Feedback is also a form of generosity. Someone has taken the time and care to read and analyse your work, and offered you their thoughts with the hope of helping you improve your craft. Ask questions, ask for clarifications, ask for the bigger picture. Note: The workshops provide a space for writers to respond to and discuss any reader questions after receiving feedback.
- Keep your ego out of the equation: Never force the issue. It’s the writer’s job to decide what to do with your comments and suggestions.
- Never reduce someone’s submission to a joke: When someone presents you with a piece of work, they are asking for feedback because they want to improve. Keep it useful!
- Seek critique on your own feedback: Feedback can be hard to take, and that is normal. During the meetings, please refrain from explaining yourself until everyone has given their feedback. This allows the writer to hear unbiased feedback about their work. As the writer, you know your work better than anyone, and you will know which feedback helps you improve and which feedback does not. Please give yourself a few days to let the feedback sink in before attempting to edit your work. This will allow you to judge your work rather than react emotionally to feedback.
Ask writers to be honest with you. Ask them if your feedback was useful if you are not sure.
When analysing a work:
- Always seek to understand: Think about the author’s objectives, and critique accordingly. Remember, the author’s intentions might be different from your preconceived notions of genre, subject, etc. If in doubt, ask.
- Use your gut instinct: It can be useful to do an initial reading at a normal pace, noting down your raw reactions along the way. Did you smile or laugh at a certain place? Did you feel angry at a certain point? Were there moments of confusion, or places where your attention wandered?
- Ask yourself why: Your first reaction to something is almost always correct, but your first explanation for why you felt this way usually is not. Once you’ve noted your raw reactions, read through again. Question yourself about why a piece made you feel happy, angry, bored, or confused. Was there not enough action? Were there too many words that did not contribute anything? Keep questioning yourself until you get an answer that leaves no unease in your mind, and that will be the true reason why the piece made you feel a certain way.
- Aim for actionable feedback: Try to turn your comments into solutions. Take the time to describe the changes you suggest. ‘I felt that the dialogue was too slow. Maybe you could cut down on XYZ which isn’t necessary’ is always more useful compared to ‘I felt it was too slow’.
When critiquing:
- Always remember, your feedback drives the discussion: The person in front of you has invested time and effort into presenting something. Make sure you proceed in a way that is constructive and useful.
- Start with what works, then go to what doesn’t work: After all, there must have been something you liked. What’s working in a piece is as important as what’s not working, as it lets the author know what their strengths are and where they should focus their attention. It’s nice to round back to some positives as you summarise at the end as well.
- Start with the big picture: Start with broad brush strokes, and then drill your way down. E.g.: ‘I did not like the pacing of the scene, but the dialogues really bring the characters to life’, followed by a discussion of the specifics, is always more useful and actionable than ‘I like this dialogue but the scene seemed too long.’
- If the author has requested feedback on something specific, make that your priority: If the author asks for feedback on the flow of the dialogue, but you have comments on the language used in the descriptions, make it a point to focus on the dialogue first, and then move on to your other feedback.
- You don’t have to share everything on the night: In order to help divide the meeting time effectively, choose a few points to discuss in front of the group. Emphasise things others haven’t already covered or areas where your opinion/interpretation differs from the group. De-prioritise line edits, which are often best shared privately. What you don’t get to say out loud can be passed to the writer afterwards.
- There is value in experience: When sharing feedback in a group, listen to those who have been in the game for a while. They have seen a lot and can provide you with insights that you didn’t know.
- There is value in inexperience: When sharing feedback in a group, listen to those who are new to the game. They might pick up something you missed, or provide a fresh perspective.
- Not all opinions matter: Figure out when you have nothing useful to contribute and stay silent. This is not a contest. Keep in mind that if most of the group members offer similar feedback, this particular feedback is likely an area that needs to be addressed in the work.
Part Two: What To Talk About In Your Feedback
Note: If the writer has asked for feedback on a specific point, give priority to feedback on that point. Aside from that, you may comment on some or all of the following:
• First and foremost:
Think of at least one thing about the story that you liked and that you would like to communicate to the writer.
• Opening:
This could apply to the opening of a whole story or a single chapter. What did you think of the first line and the first paragraph? Could they be stronger, or did they do a sufficient job to reel you in? Did the story/chapter meet the expectations set by the opening? Are the stakes of the story clearly established in the first 1-2 pages? Does the story have enough of a problem driving it forward?
• Language & Vividness:
How would you describe the language? Spare, direct, lyrical? How about the tone? Did the writer make good use of the senses to evoke a certain mood? Are setting and characters vivid? Might the story improve with more/less use of direct speech? Is the writer showing instead of telling?
• Characters:
How successful was the writer at revealing characters? What tools did the writer use – dialogue, description, dialect? Was there a good balance between showing and telling? Were the characters round and complex or flat/stereotypical? Did their actions and decisions feel true to form?
• Setting:
Does the setting make sense? Is there anything about it which intrigues or confuses you? Is it described in sufficient detail? Too much? Does it support your sense of the characters and the plot? Do you have any comments on the technology or mythology used in the story?
• Plot and Pacing:
Did the story/chapter engage you? Did it move too fast or too slow? Where would you suggest that the writer speed up or slow down, and how? Are there any passages you would cut? What do you think of the balance between plot/direct action and background? Does the plot seem to grow organically from the characters and setting, or does it feel forced? Does the story/chapter end at a suitable place?
• Narrative point of view (POV):
What did you think of the POV choice? Was it used consistently? How would the story be different if the writer had made a different narrative choice?
• Theme:
What do you think the story is about? Does the writer make use of symbolism? How would you suggest that the writer further reveal the story’s theme? Does the writer avoid clichés? Does the writer’s relationship with the material seem authentic? Do they know what they are talking about?
For more information on Workshops, please have a look at: What Are Creative Writing Groups & How To Find The Right One For You
